Different election, same playbook: Why 2014 looks like 2012 - KTTC Rochester, Austin, Mason City News, Weather and Sports

Different election, same playbook: Why 2014 will look a lot like 2012

Posted:

WASHINGTON (NBC News) -- In 2012, the electoral battle lines were clear: Democrats painted the race as a struggle between a dynamic incumbent and a lesser GOP foe, while Republicans made it a referendum on the president and his health care law. It's a playbook that both parties are reaching into for the 2014 midterm election, with Republicans and Democrats both looking to expand their influence on Capitol Hill.

In recent days, President Barack Obama has made a point of highlighting his own proposals as a means of arguing that Republicans don't just have a bad plan – they have no plans.

"You owe it to the American people to tell us what you are for, not just what you're against," the president said earlier this month in an economic speech that foreshadowed one of the key narratives of the 2014 campaign. "That way we can have a vigorous and meaningful debate."

Republicans, in turn, have been resurgent in recent weeks after stumbling through a government shutdown for which many Americans had blamed them. The GOP's been resuscitated by the troubled launch of insurance markets under the Affordable Care Act, an animating issue for the party during their 2010 charge to power in Congress.

But it's unclear whether Republicans can find success next fall simply by highlighting their opposition to Obama and his signature health reform law. If they were to opt for such a strategy, they would essentially follow in the footsteps of GOP nominee Mitt Romney, whose attempt to transform last year's presidential election into a referendum on Obama ended up being a losing strategy.

"I think it's more than enough to make it a referendum on [Obama]," Republican pollster Jim McLaughlin said of the GOP's 2014 strategy. "The White House is driving the agenda and the agenda's not popular."

Republicans appear to be sensitive, though, to perceptions that they have accomplished little during their second term in control of the House. As congressional productivity hit record lows, House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, took to the House floor on Tuesday to highlight the 150 or so (mostly partisan) bills approved by the House that have died in the Senate.

"Every single one of these bills has been blocked by Washington Democrats," Boehner said. "The Senate and the president continue to stand in the way of the people's priorities."

But the speaker also crystallized the dilemma for Republicans earlier this week when he punted on a question about whether the House would produce and vote upon a Republican alternative to Obamacare sometime in 2014. "We'll see," he said.

"I think Democrats are going to try to force these kind of ‘choice' elections," said Democratic strategist Doug Thornell, "forcing the conversation into a choice between what the president and what Democrats are offering, and what Republicans want to offer."

Applying a grand narrative – whether the election is a choice between Democrats and Republicans, or a referendum on Obama – is far more difficult in a series of congressional elections, though, than it is in a presidential election. For starters, the number of competitive House seats has been diminished by redistricting efforts. And House races in particular often assume a more local flavor that might not always mirror national storylines.

House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi of California talks about the problem of insurers dropping coverage for tens of thousands of Americans.

It's somewhat easier, however, to nationalize Senate races. And the Senate is the primary battleground of the 2014 midterm elections, when Republicans will try to net six seats to retake the upper chamber and strengthen their hand on Capitol Hill.

Brian Walsh, a veteran of the campaign committee which helps elect Republicans to the Senate, suggested that GOP Senate candidates cannot simply rest their campaigns on being anti-Obamacare.

"It cannot just be about Obamacare," Walsh said of his party's 2014 strategy. "It's obviously an enormous political problem for Democrats, but it's also important for Republicans to talk about their own positive ideas and alternatives to replacing that."

Republicans are eager to point out the variety of plans floating around Capitol Hill that they say would form the basis of their alternative to Obamacare. But there's no central proposal behind which Republicans can rally; GOP candidates aren't equipped with talking points to explain an available Republican insurance alternative, because there is none.

In that sense, the GOP could be vulnerable to Obama's latest arguments. The president has argued that Republicans have no plan on health care beyond repealing his law, and has extended that argument to economic policy and even immigration reform. (A bipartisan Senate immigration bill has languished in the House, where Republicans want to break the law into separate pieces but have not done so yet.)

There's still time for Republicans to produce and coalesce around alternative proposals in 2014, but the process of legislating will almost certainly become more difficult as individual lawmakers turn their attention toward tending to their own re-election campaigns.

And creating consensus around big new policies isn't always easy. Conservatives balked earlier this year at a modest proposal from House Majority Leader Eric Cantor, R-Va., to help expand high-risk insurance pools, an embarrassment to one of the No. 2 Republican's efforts to soften the GOP's image on health care.

"They need to show and demonstrate that they can operate effectively in Washington and do something for their voters," said Thornell, the Democratic strategist. "And right now they don't really have anything to which they can really point."

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Man killed in random knife attack at California steakhouse

    Man killed in random knife attack at California steakhouse

    Saturday, April 21 2018 10:29 PM EDT2018-04-22 02:29:16 GMT
    (Ventura County District Attorney's Office via AP). This undated photo provided by the Ventura County District Attorney's Office shows Jamal Jackson. The homeless man has been charged with murder in a random stabbing attack in which a man was killed wh...(Ventura County District Attorney's Office via AP). This undated photo provided by the Ventura County District Attorney's Office shows Jamal Jackson. The homeless man has been charged with murder in a random stabbing attack in which a man was killed wh...
    A homeless man has been charged with murder in the death of a California father who was stabbed in the neck as his 5-year-old daughter sat in his lap in a crowded beachside steakhouse.More >>
    A homeless man has been charged with murder in the death of a California father who was stabbed in the neck as his 5-year-old daughter sat in his lap in a crowded beachside steakhouse.More >>
  • Rochester couple displays their eco-friendly dream home

    Rochester couple displays their eco-friendly dream home

    The home is the couples vision for an environment friendly future and their dream home they hope to retire in.

    More >>

    The home is the couples vision for an environment friendly future and their dream home they hope to retire in.

    More >>
  • Dodge County Sheriff's Office says Riess likely to be tried in Florida first

    Dodge County Sheriff's Office says Riess likely to be tried in Florida first

    Friday morning, KTTC learned from Dodge County Sheriff Scott Rose at a press conference that investigators want to build a strong case against Lois Riess before charging her with the murder of her husband David Riess. She already faces a second degree murder charge in Florida for the murder of Pamela Hutchinson. 

    More >>

    Friday morning, KTTC learned from Dodge County Sheriff Scott Rose at a press conference that investigators want to build a strong case against Lois Riess before charging her with the murder of her husband David Riess. She already faces a second degree murder charge in Florida for the murder of Pamela Hutchinson. 

    More >>
  • Timeline takes shape after Lois Riess's Arrest

    Timeline takes shape after Lois Riess's Arrest

    It all started on March 23rd when David Riess was found dead in his home with multiple gunshot wounds. Friends say they hadn't heard from him for a of couple weeks.  When authorities showed up to the house, they say he had long been dead. 

    More >>

    It all started on March 23rd when David Riess was found dead in his home with multiple gunshot wounds. Friends say they hadn't heard from him for a of couple weeks.  When authorities showed up to the house, they say he had long been dead. 

    More >>
  • Second suspect in Rochester's Cold Stone robbery arrested at work

    Second suspect in Rochester's Cold Stone robbery arrested at work

    From left to right: Andres Green and Keshawn HowellFrom left to right: Andres Green and Keshawn Howell
    From left to right: Andres Green and Keshawn HowellFrom left to right: Andres Green and Keshawn Howell
    The trail to catch a suspected robber leads police from ice cream to coffee. It took an off-duty officer's trip through a coffee-shop drive thru to spot a suspect at the center of an ice-cream shop burglary earlier this year.  According to Rochester police, the officer was waiting for his brew Thursday morning in Northwest Rochester when he noticed 19-year-old Andres Green working inside the shop. Uniformed cops arrived shortly after to make the arrest. A warrant ...More >>
    The trail to catch a suspected robber leads police from ice cream to coffee. It took an off-duty officer's trip through a coffee-shop drive thru to spot a suspect at the center of an ice-cream shop burglary earlier this year.  According to Rochester police, the officer was waiting for his brew Thursday morning in Northwest Rochester when he noticed 19-year-old Andres Green working inside the shop. Uniformed cops arrived shortly after to make the arrest. A warrant ...More >>
  • Minnesota judge orders release of files in Wetterling case

    Minnesota judge orders release of files in Wetterling case

    A district judge ruled that any files connected to the investigation of a criminal case become public record once the case is concluded.

    More >>

    A district judge ruled that any files connected to the investigation of a criminal case become public record once the case is concluded.

    More >>
  • State Farm cutting auto insurance rates in Minnesota

    State Farm cutting auto insurance rates in Minnesota

    If you have State Farm as your auto insurance, you may be in luck. The auto insurer decided to cut insurance rates in Minnesota. 

    More >>

    If you have State Farm as your auto insurance, you may be in luck. The auto insurer decided to cut insurance rates in Minnesota. 

    More >>
  • Suspected Florida school shooter appears in court

    Suspected Florida school shooter appears in court

    Saturday, April 21 2018 5:54 PM EDT2018-04-21 21:54:35 GMT
    (Doug Engle/Ocala Star-Banner via AP). Marion County Sheriff's Detectives John Lightle, left, and Dan Pinder, right, escort a handcuffed and shackled Sky Bouche, 19, center, to a waiting patrol car, Friday, April 20, 2018, in Ocala, Fla. Bouche is the ...(Doug Engle/Ocala Star-Banner via AP). Marion County Sheriff's Detectives John Lightle, left, and Dan Pinder, right, escort a handcuffed and shackled Sky Bouche, 19, center, to a waiting patrol car, Friday, April 20, 2018, in Ocala, Fla. Bouche is the ...
    A gunman carrying a shotgun in a guitar case opened fire at a Florida high school, wounding one student as other students and teachers piled desks and cabinets against classroom doors to make barricades.More >>
    A gunman carrying a shotgun in a guitar case opened fire at a Florida high school, wounding one student as other students and teachers piled desks and cabinets against classroom doors to make barricades.More >>
Powered by Frankly